“Analysis of Capa’s photos is provided on an in-depth level, with some photos being picked apart piece by piece. This level of analysis shows Herrick to be both a skilled historian and a photographic analyst… well written, concise, and does an excellent job of sorting fact from fantasy.” — The Journal of America's Military Past
Although Capa's Falling Soldier image from the Spanish Civil War has been definitively proven to be a staged propaganda fake, no one has applied a similarly critical eye to his later work. This book is the first effort to establish the facts behind the fables surrounding his D-Day adventures and the images he produced during that period. This book examines the fictionalized account Robert Capa penned in his pseudo biography Slightly Out of Focus. Written in the hopes of it becoming a movie, Capa included many elements which were exaggerated or simply not true, while omitting many relevant events. As he himself said in the dust jacket for that book: “Writing the truth being obviously so difficult, I have in the interests of it allowed myself to go sometimes slightly beyond and slightly this side of it. All events and persons in the book are accidental and have something to do with the truth.”
This new account carefully details the actual events surrounding Capa's D-Day adventures, using official SHAEF files, still and motion picture images taken by other cameramen who were near or with Capa, and a variety of accounts of witnesses. It examines several aspects of Capa's narrative and reveals the truth behind the fiction: he claimed that he landed in the First Wave with Company E, in reality he landed almost two hours later in Wave 13 with the regimental commander. Analysis reveals how many of his images were presented in a false context and as a result have been misinterpreted for decades. Building on Allan Colleman and his team's proof that the bulk of Capa D-Day photos could not possibly have been ruined in a darkroom accident, this gripping expose details the effects the FORTITUDE deception plans had on censorship, and how the censorship system would have retained the images popularly thought to have been lost.
Introduction
Part One: To The Normandy Coast Chapter 1. A Change of Scenery Chapter 2. Pressing Matters Chapter 3. The Channel Crossing Chapter 4. D-Day, The Plan Chapter 5. Capa and the ‘First Wave with Company E’ Myth Chapter 6. A Second Look at the First Wave Chapter 7. D-Day, The Reality Chapter 8. The Lousy Civilian Idea
Part Two: Ramps Down Chapter 9. Where, Exactly? Chapter 10. When, Exactly? Chapter 11. Easy Red at 0830 Hours Chapter 12. One Hundred Forty Minutes in an LCVP Chapter 13. Capa On The Beach – In His Own Contradictory Words Chapter 14. The Debarkation Set Chapter 15. The Engineer Set Chapter 16. The Face in the Surf Chapter 17. The Obstacle Forest Set
Part Three: Beat Feet To The Fleet Chapter 18. Day Tripper? Chapter 19. Flight Chapter 20. Early Boarding Chapter 21. Chase, Again Chapter 22. Camera Confusion Chapter 23. Return To The Near Shore Chapter 24. Film Follies
Charles Herrick graduated from the US military Academy at West Point in 1974. Commissioned in the Infantry, he earned the Ranger tab and Master Parachutist’s wings. He served in a variety of positions from company grade to the Pentagon. He earned the Combat Infantryman’s badge while assigned as the Operations Officer of the 193d Infantry Brigade in Panama in 1989, and later graduated from the US Army War College. After retiring from the Army in 1996, he continued to work on defense issues as a contractor. He has worked in East Asia, Latin America, the Balkans, Africa and Central Asia. He holds an MBA from the University of California at Los Angeles. After fully retiring in 2018, he lives in Kansas with his wife, where he pursues his passion for military history.
“Analysis of Capa’s photos is provided on an in-depth level, with some photos being picked apart piece by piece. This level of analysis shows Herrick to be both a skilled historian and a photographic analyst… well written, concise, and does an excellent job of sorting fact from fantasy.”
~The Journal of America's Military Past
“No military historian has ever subjected a set of war photographs to a forensic analysis comparable to what Charles Herrick achieves in Back into Focus. He brings to the project a combat veteran's experience, a dedicated researcher's commitment to excavating the truth, an ability to navigate military archives and decipher military documents, and the writing skills necessary to make all that he has uncovered accessible and fascinating to even a lay reader. Nothing like this exists in the literature of photography, photojournalism, or military history; it sets a very high bar.”
~A. D. Coleman, director, Alternate History: The Capa D-Day Project
“… a detailed reference for historians specializing in World War II public affairs activities of D-Day. It is also illuminating for museum curators and war photography curators who may be unwittingly propagating the exaggerations debunked by Herrick and his predecessors.”
~Military Review
“…possesses superb research, sound analysis, and offers a hyper-detailed look at a tiny slice of history.”
~Historical Miniatures Gaming Society
“It is exceptionally well researched. If you want to read about how Robert Capa's Omaha adventure on the 6th June was not as advertised, then this is the book for you.”
~Army Rumour Service